How to Turn First-Time Donors Into Repeat Supporters

group of friends sitting near lifeguard post

Your year-end fundraising campaign brings in 100 new donors. Everyone celebrates. Your fundraising goal is closer, your board is happy, and your team can finally breathe. Yay!

But there’s a problem.

What happens to those 100 donors next year?

If your nonprofit is like many others, most of them may never give again.

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project reported that overall donor retention was 18.0 percent  in Q1 of this year. It also found that retention fell among small, midsize, major, and supersize donor groups during the quarter.

This is one of the biggest missed opportunities in nonprofit fundraising.

Getting a donation is the start of a relationship, not the end of a campaign.

With GivingTuesday arriving on December 1 and the year-end giving season right behind it, you need to plan what happens after someone gives.

The Blackbaud Institute found that 36 percent of annual fundraising revenue arrived in the fourth quarter of 2025. December was the most important month.

Here are five ways to turn first-time donors into long-term supporters.

1. Donors Are People, Too

Think about the last time someone thanked you in a way that felt genuine.

You probably remember it.

Now think about a receipt that said, “Thank you for your donation.”

That’s not very genuine.

Many nonprofits send automatic donation receipts. The receipt may meet legal or record-keeping needs, but it does not make the donor feel connected to the mission.

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project estimated overall donor retention at 42.9 percent for 2024. In its report covering the first nine months of that year, 13.8 percent of new donors had been retained.

A donor has trusted your organization with their money. Show them that the decision mattered.

Here is what to do:

  • Send a thank-you message as soon as possible.
  • Use the donor’s name
  • Mention what they supported
  • Keep the message warm, short and easy to understand

Instead of saying, “Thank you for your generous contribution to our organization,” try:

“Thank you, Sarah, for helping local families get the food they need. Your support keeps our shelves stocked and our neighbors fed.”

Only make promises your organization can support.

Do not turn your thank-you message into another donation request.

Let people enjoy the feeling of having helped. Invite them to take another step later.

2. Show Donors What Their Gifts Made Possible

People want to know their support matters.

They don’t want another long report full of numbers, charts and formal language.

This is where a short, real story makes a difference.

Imagine that your nonprofit helps young adults with disabilities find jobs.

Instead of sending a message that says, “We served 250 people this year,” tell the story of one person who gained new skills, found work and became more independent. That would be super meaningful to me.

The goal is to connect the donation to the mission.

Here are three ways to do that:

Share one story. Introduce a person, family or community member who benefited from your work. Explain the challenge and what changed.

Show the work behind the results. Let donors see the staff, volunteers and programs that make your mission possible.

Explain what comes next. Tell supporters what your organization is working toward and why continued support matters.

Get permission before sharing personal stories, photos or videos.

When donors understand the difference their support makes, they have a clearer reason to stay involved.

3. Don’t Disappear After December 31

Many nonprofits spend weeks preparing campaigns.

They plan emails, create graphics, post on social media, and ask supporters to give before the deadline.

Then January hit, and the team moves on. Oh deer.

That is a problem.

A donor who gives in December may still be learning about your nonprofit. They may not know your staff, understand your programs, or realize how they can help beyond making a donation.

Silence leaves those questions unanswered.

You need a simple plan for staying in touch.

Try this schedule for first-time donors:

Within 24 hours: Send a personal, warm thank-you message and donation receipt.

Within seven days: Share a short story, photo or update that connects their gift to your mission.

Within 30 days: Introduce another part of your work. Explain a problem your organization is solving or share a recent achievement.

Within 60 days: Invite the donor to take part in something meaningful. This might be an event, volunteer activity, online briefing, or community program.

Within 90 days: Share a useful update and explain what your organization hopes to accomplish next.

These are starting points, not universal rules. Adjust the timing to fit your donors, your mission and your communication schedule.

Make every message worth opening.

Don’t send something simply because the calendar says it is time. Give people a reason to care.

4. Stop Sending Every Donor the Same Message

Your donors are not all alike.

One person might give $25 after seeing a friend’s social media post. Another might donate $1,000.

They have different relationships with your mission.

Yet many nonprofits send all three people the same email.

Start with three simple groups:

First-time donors: Help them understand your work, meet your people, and see the impact of their support.

Repeat donors: Thank them for continuing to stand with your organization. Share progress and explain what their ongoing support makes possible.

Major donors: When appropriate, arrange personal outreach from your executive director, development director or another staff member who can build a genuine relationship.

You can also group donors by the causes they care about.

The point is to make your communication more relevant.

Remember, personalization is more than inserting someone’s first name into an email. It means showing that you understand why they chose to support you.

5. Measure What Happens

Your fundraising team probably tracks how much money a campaign raises.

That matters. But it does not tell the whole story.

You should also track what happens to the people who give.

Start with simple numbers:

  • New donors: How many people gave to your organization for the first time?
  • Second gifts: How many first-time donors made another donation?
  • Donor retention: What percentage of previous donors gave again during the period you are measuring?
  • Revenue from repeat donors: How much money came from people who had supported you before?

Your donor management system or a simple spreadsheet may be enough to begin.

Review these numbers each quarter. Compare results over time and look for patterns.

Stop treating the donation total as the only measure of success.

A campaign that brings in fewer new donors but builds stronger, lasting relationships may be more valuable.

Build More Than Revenue

The end of the year is a major fundraising opportunity. You want supporters to understand your mission, trust your organization, and feel connected to the work.

That takes thoughtful communication before, during and after the gift.

Start small. Write a better thank-you message. Prepare useful donor updates. Create a simple follow-up calendar. Track the data.

You do not need to do everything at once.

Before your next fundraising campaign launches, answer one question: What will we do to help a first-time donor become a second-time donor?

If your team has a clear answer, you are already thinking beyond the next donation.

That is where stronger donor relationships begin.

Published by Ryan Wilson

CEO of Team Trust

Leave a Reply