Your Nonprofit Has Outgrown Its Marketing Strategy. Now What?

woman posing in sunglasses

Your nonprofit has more programs, more employees, more donors and bigger goals than it did 5 years ago.

That’s great, but your marketing … is pretty much the same.

You’re still posting on the same social media channels. You’re still sending the same types of emails. You’re still relying on the same handful of people to spread the word.

When someone asks how marketing is helping the organization grow, the answer isn’t always clear.

An organization can outgrow its marketing strategy without anyone noticing until the results start to suffer.

The strategy that helped you get from $1 million to $3 million in annual revenue is not be the strategy that gets you to $10 million.

Your organization has changed. Your marketing should, too.

You need to build a marketing strategy that matches the organization you have today and the organization you want to become.

Here’s how.

1. Recognize the signs that your marketing strategy is outdated

Let’s figure out whether you actually have a problem.

A growing nonprofit doesn’t automatically need a bigger marketing budget. It needs a better connection between its marketing and its goals.

Here are five warning signs that your current approach may be holding you back.

You’re reaching the same people over and over.

Your social media followers are familiar with your organization. Your email subscribers already know what you do. Your regular donors keep showing up.

How many new people are discovering you?

If most of your marketing reaches people who already support your mission, you may be missing opportunities to attract volunteers, new donors, corporate sponsors and community partners.

Your marketing is disconnected from fundraising.

If your marketing calendar has little connection to fundraising campaigns, donor needs or major events, you’re missing a chance to make each effort stronger.

Your content hasn’t changed as your organization has grown.

Five years ago, a few pictures and a short description of your programs may have been enough.

Today, you may have multiple programs, major partnerships, impressive outcomes and a much larger audience to reach.

Yet your website and social media tell the same basic story.

Your team is constantly reacting.

Someone needs a graphic. Another department wants an email. The CEO needs a presentation. An event is coming up, and nobody has started promoting it.

Your marketing team spends its time completing requests, instead of leading a plan.

You can’t clearly explain what marketing contributes.

You know your team is working hard.

Can you connect its work to more qualified prospects, stronger donor relationships, event attendance, fundraising results or greater awareness?

If not, it’s time to rethink how you approach marketing.

2. Stop asking, “What should we post?” Start asking, “What are we trying to accomplish?”

Too many organizations build their marketing plans around content.

Publishing content isn’t the same as making progress.

Start with three questions:

  • Who do we need to reach?
  • What do we want those people to understand or do?
  • How will we know if we made progress?

Let’s say your nonprofit wants to attract more corporate sponsors for its annual fundraising event.

Your marketing strategy could include:

  • A short video showing the difference your organization makes
  • Stories that demonstrate why local businesses should support your work
  • LinkedIn content aimed at business owners and corporate decision-makers
  • Email messages explaining sponsorship opportunities
  • Video clips from previous events that show the experience sponsors can expect

Now your marketing has a purpose.

Instead of measuring success by how many things you publish, measure whether your marketing is helping move people closer to becoming supporters.

3. Build a marketing strategy around the organization you want to become

Growing nonprofits build their marketing around today’s needs without thinking about tomorrow’s goals.

If you want to double your fundraising, expand into new communities, launch programs, or attract larger corporate partners, your marketing needs to support those goals before you get there.

Start by reviewing your organization’s strategic plan.

Look at the next 12 to 24 months.

What are the biggest priorities?

Maybe you want to:

  • Increase individual donations
  • Attract more major donors
  • Expand into two new cities
  • Grow corporate sponsorships
  • Increase attendance at fundraising events
  • Build awareness among a new audience

Choose your three most-important goals.

Ask how marketing can achieve each one.

For example:

Organizational goalMarketing opportunity
Attract new donorsShare compelling stories that introduce people to your mission
Grow corporate sponsorshipsCreate professional impact and event videos for potential partners
Expand into new communitiesPublish local stories and targeted educational content
Increase donor retentionSend regular updates showing what donations make possible
Grow event attendanceUse short videos, email, and social content to build excitement

This exercise costs nothing.

Marketing becomes a partner in achieving the organization’s biggest goals.

4. Stop treating video as a one-time expense

Here’s an opportunity many nonprofits overlook.

They spend thousands of dollars producing a video, publish it once, and move on.

Six months later, that video is sitting on their website or buried somewhere on their YouTube channel.

What a waste.

A good video can support your marketing for months or even years. But only if you plan how to use it.

Think about a 2-minute video featuring someone whose life has changed because of your nonprofit.

That one video could become:

  • A short fundraising appeal
  • Three or four social media clips
  • A donor newsletter feature
  • A presentation for corporate sponsors
  • A section of your annual report
  • A follow-up message after a fundraising event
  • A resource for your website

One production. Multiple marketing opportunities.

Stop thinking about video as something you purchase for a single campaign.

It is an asset that helps your organization tell its story across multiple channels.

This is especially important as your nonprofit grows. More people need to understand your work, and you need more ways to reach them.

5. Decide what to keep, improve, stop, and outsource

You probably don’t need to replace your entire marketing operation.

Some things are working. Others need attention. And a few may be wasting valuable time.

Review your current marketing activities and place each one into one of four groups.

KEEP: What’s producing good results?

Perhaps your monthly donor newsletter generates strong engagement. Keep it.

IMPROVE: What’s worth doing but could perform better?

Maybe your fundraising videos receive plenty of views but don’t give viewers a clear next step. Improve the message and call to action.

STOP: What’s consuming time without supporting your goals?

Perhaps your team spends hours creating content for a platform that rarely reaches your target audience. Reduce that effort.

OUTSOURCE: What requires skills or time your team doesn’t have?

This could include professional video production, editing, social media content, campaign planning, or event promotion.

Outsourcing doesn’t mean losing control.

You should own your mission, your message and your relationships with supporters.

You don’t need to hire a full-time employee for every skill your marketing strategy requires.

A strong outside partner can bring specialized knowledge, fresh ideas and production capacity without requiring you to build another department.

Be careful about who you hire.

7. Give your new strategy 90 days to prove itself

You don’t need a 50-page marketing plan.

You need a clear direction and a way to act on it.

Here’s a simple 90-day starting point.

Time frameWhat to do
Days 1–15Review your current marketing, results, audiences and organizational goals
Days 16–30Choose three priorities and decide which activities to keep, improve, stop or outsource
Days 31–60Launch updated campaigns, improve existing content and test new approaches
Days 61–90Review results, identify what worked and adjust the plan

Bring your executive director, marketing leader and development leader into the conversation.

They should agree on the organization’s biggest priorities.

Your team needs to understand the goals early enough to help shape how the organization reaches them.

Your nonprofit has grown. Your marketing should show it.

Your organization has worked hard to get where it is today.

You’ve built programs, helped people, attracted supporters and earned the trust of your community.

Your marketing should make that progress visible.

If you’re still using the same approach you used when your organization was half its current size, you are leaving opportunities on the table.

You need a strategy that connects your organization’s goals with the people you need to reach.

And you need the right people and partners to help make that happen.

At Team Trust Productions, we’re a disability led video production and marketing company that helps nonprofits turn their stories into stronger relationships, bigger audiences, and more fundraising opportunities.

Not only that, we can make you an additional $80,000 in as little as 30 days!

Not sure whether your current video content is doing enough for your organization?

Request a free 15-minute video marketing review from Team Trust Productions.

We’ll look at your existing video assets and identify three ways you could get more marketing and fundraising value from them.

Published by Ryan Wilson

CEO of Team Trust

Leave a Reply