Imagine your nonprofit spends $30,000 on marketing this year.
You hire an agency. You run paid ads. You produce videos. You sponsor events. You pay for software. You post on social media.
The money goes out the door.
When someone asks what that spending actually accomplished, you hear crickets.
Uh … Website traffic went up, you say. Social media followers increased. And lots of content.
But did you raise money?
Nobody is sure.
Your nonprofit may have a marketing spending problem.
Spending more money doesn’t automatically create growth. Sometimes, it simply helps you do more of the wrong things.
That’s an expensive mistake.
The goal is to make every marketing dollar work harder.
Let’s look at how to do that.
Confusing Activity With Results
Let’s say two nonprofits each spend $30,000 on marketing.
Nonprofit A produces 40 social media graphics, publishes 12 blog posts, runs several ad campaigns, and gains 2,000 followers. Good!
Nonprofit B produces fewer pieces of content. Instead, it focuses on donor stories, improves its fundraising emails, creates a compelling campaign video, and builds a plan to stay in touch with supporters throughout the year. Heck ya!
Which nonprofit gets better results?
You can’t answer that by counting how much content each organization produced.
You need to look at what happened because of the spending.
Did more people donate? Did existing donors give again? Did event attendance increase?
Marketing activity is what your organization does. Marketing results are what those activities help accomplish.
If a marketing partner cannot explain how its work supports your organization’s goals, you should question what you’re paying for.
Four Ways Nonprofits Waste Marketing Money Without Realizing It
Not every marketing expense is wasteful. Some common habits can drain your budget without creating much value.
Here are five worth examining.
1. Paying for content without a plan for using it
Imagine spending $5,000 on a beautiful fundraising video.
You publish it on your website and share it on Facebook.
Then it disappears.
Three weeks later, nobody is talking about it.
A good video can support fundraising emails, donor presentations, social media posts, event promotions, grant applications and sponsor conversations.
One project can create many opportunities to reach people.
Before approving your next content project, ask:
- Where will we publish it?
- Who needs to see it?
- What action should viewers take?
- How can we reuse it?
- How long can we continue getting value from it?
The goal is to get lasting value from the work.
2. Chasing attention instead of building relationships
Let’s say a post gets 10,000 views. That’s impressive.
How many viewers visited your website? How many became donors?
Your nonprofit needs people to move beyond seeing your name. You want them to understand your mission, trust your organization and stay connected.
That takes more than occasional social media posts.
For example, imagine someone watches a 30-second video about a person your organization helped.
Instead of simply hoping they remember you, give them a next step.
Invite them to read the full story, sign up for updates, attend an event, or make a donation.
Every piece of content should have a job.
3. Hiring several vendors who don’t work together
Your nonprofit hires one company for social media, another for video, another for website work, and another for advertising.
Oh dear.
Each company will tend to do its own thing.
You end up paying several people to work on separate pieces of the same puzzle.
This creates extra costs, mixed messages and missed opportunities.
It also creates more work for your staff.
Your marketing partners should understand your larger goals and work together toward them.
4. Buying tools before fixing the process
New software can be exciting.
But here’s a question: Did that purchases solve an actual problem?
A new tool won’t fix an unclear message. Better software won’t create a compelling donor story. Another social media platform won’t magically give your team more time.
Before purchasing anything, identify the problem.
Then ask whether the tool will solve it.
Sometimes the best investment is not another subscription. It’s a better plan.
Your Nonprofit Marketing Budget Needs a Job Description
Think of your marketing like a fundraising team. You wouldn’t hire five people without knowing what you expect them to accomplish.
Your marketing budget deserves the same level of thought.
Here are three ways to make it work harder.
1. Start with the result
Before spending money, decide what you want to happen. Be specific, too.
For example:
| Instead of this goal | Set this goal |
|---|---|
| Get more social media followers | Bring 200 qualified visitors to our donation page |
| Produce more videos | Create three videos to support our next fundraising campaign |
| Send more emails | Increase donations from our existing email list |
| Get more website traffic | Increase inquiries about our programs |
| Promote our annual gala | Increase ticket sales and attract new sponsors |
Notice the difference?
The first column describes things you can do. The second describes what you want those activities to accomplish.
You can still track followers, views and website visits. Just don’t confuse them with the final result.
A good marketing plan connects every major expense to something the organization wants to achieve.
2. Measure what happens after someone sees your marketing
Let’s say you spend $2,000 promoting a fundraising campaign.
You receive 50,000 impressions.
That’s interesting, but it doesn’t tell you whether the campaign worked.
You need to follow the journey.
How many people clicked? How many visited the donation page? How many completed a donation? How much money came in? How many people gave again later?
You should also look beyond immediate donations.
A video introducing your organization might not generate a donation that afternoon. But it could help a potential major donor understand your mission before an important meeting.
That value matters, too.
Here are some useful numbers to track:
| Marketing activity | What to measure |
|---|---|
| Fundraising campaigns | Donations, revenue, average gift |
| Donor emails | Clicks, donations, repeat giving |
| Social media | Relevant reach, website visits, inquiries |
| Video | Views, completion, clicks, actions |
| Events | Ticket sales, attendance, sponsorships |
| Website | Donation conversions, inquiries, sign-ups |
You don’t need expensive software to start.
A simple spreadsheet can help you track spending, results, and lessons learned.
The important thing is to measure something beyond how much work got completed.
3. Review your spending every 90 days
Set aside an hour every three months to review your marketing expenses.
Ask these questions:
- What did we spend money on?
- What results did we get?
- Which activities helped us reach our goals?
- Which expenses produced little value?
- What should we stop, improve or invest more in?
You might discover that a campaign performed much better than expected.
Or the opposite!
Either way, you now have information to make a better decision.
Look at the full picture before making changes.
Here’s the Part Many Marketing Companies Won’t Tell You
Too many marketing providers focus on selling individual services.
More videos. More posts. More ads. More monthly retainers.
Your nonprofit deserves a partner who starts with your goals, looks at the resources you already have, identifies opportunities, and helps you make smarter decisions.
That means asking difficult questions before recommending another expense.
It also means understanding that your marketing doesn’t exist to keep an agency busy.
It exists to help your organization accomplish something meaningful.
At Team Trust Productions, that’s how we believe nonprofit marketing should work.
As a disability led video production and marketing company, we help nonprofits use storytelling, video, and thoughtful marketing to reach people, build trust, engage supporters and support fundraising.
We believe your organization should get as much value as possible from the stories, resources and relationships it already has.
Want to find more value in the marketing you’ve already paid for?
Team Trust Productions offers a free 15-minute video marketing review for nonprofits.
We’ll look at your existing video assets and identify three ways you could get more marketing and fundraising value from them.
No obligation. No pressure to buy another video.
Just three practical opportunities you can explore.