The Nonprofit Marketing Audit: 15 Things to Check Before 2027

people workin together in the office

Your nonprofit may spend thousands of dollars on marketing next year.

But here’s a question to consider:

Do you know which parts of your marketing actually help your organization grow?

You might have a busy social media calendar, a monthly newsletter, a website full of information, and a fundraising video that hasn’t been watched since your last gala.

That doesn’t mean your marketing is working.

Often, I see people confuse doing marketing with getting results from marketing.

It’s time to take a closer look.

A nonprofit marketing audit helps you find what’s working, what isn’t, where money is being wasted, and where hidden opportunities might be waiting.

It’s like a health checkup for your marketing.

Here are 15 things to examine before next year.

1. Does Your Marketing Support Your Fundraising Goals?

This is a big one.

Your marketing should help your organization raise money. It should also support other important goals, such as attracting volunteers, building awareness, and developing community partnerships.

But can you connect those activities to your goals?

For example:

  • Does your email marketing bring in donations?
  • Do your event promotions sell more tickets?
  • Do your videos help potential donors understand your impact?
  • Does your website make it easy for people to support your mission?

If your marketing team is busy but your fundraising team cannot see how that work helps them, we got a problem.

What to do: List your top three goals for 2027. Then connect every major marketing activity to at least one of them.

If an activity supports none of your goals, ask why you’re doing it.

2. Is Your Website Turning Visitors Into Supporters?

Your website is often the first place potential donors, sponsors, volunteers and partners learn about your organization.

Look at your website as if you have never heard of your nonprofit.

Can a first-time visitor quickly answer these questions:

  • What does your organization do?
  • Who does it help?
  • Why does the work matter?
  • What makes your organization worth supporting?
  • What should I do next?

Pay special attention to your donation page.

A beautiful website that makes donating difficult is like a fundraising event with no way to accept money.

What to do: Ask three people unfamiliar with your organization to visit your website and make a donation. Watch where they get confused.

3. Is Your Website Easy to Use on a Phone?

Your website might look fantastic on a large computer screen.

What happens when someone visits it on a phone?

Check your video, homepage, donation pages, event registration, contact forms, etc.

Look for:

  • Text that is too small.
  • Buttons that are difficult to tap.
  • Forms that take forever to complete.
  • Images that load slowly.
  • Donation pages that are hard to navigate.

Don’t assume everything works because it looks fine on your computer.

What to do: Complete a donation on your phone. Time yourself. Fix anything that makes the process harder than it needs to be.

4. Are You Measuring the Right Numbers?

Let’s talk about one of marketing’s favorite distractions: likes.

A post gets 200 likes. Everyone celebrates. Woohoo.

But did anyone donate, register for an event, sign up for your newsletter, or become a volunteer???

Likes and followers can be useful. They are not the same as results.

Review these numbers:

  • Website visitors and donation conversions.
  • Email clicks and donations
  • Event registrations and ticket sales
  • New donors and returning donors
  • Social media engagement and website traffic
  • Cost per new donor, where you can measure it

You need a few numbers to make better decisions.

What to do: Create a simple monthly marketing report with five to ten numbers connected to your organization’s goals.

5. Is Your Email List Healthy?

Your email list is an important asset. Unlike social media followers, you have a direct way to reach people who have agreed to hear from you.

When was the last time you examined that list?

Look for:

  • Old addresses that no longer work.
  • Subscribers who have not opened or clicked anything in a long time.
  • Donors who receive messages that do not match their interests.
  • People who signed up but never received a welcome email.
  • Missing donor or supporter information.

Also, review how often you’re sending messages.

The 2026 M+R Benchmarks report found that nonprofits sent an average of 50 emails per subscriber in 2025. Email revenue increased by 16 percent on average. Performance varied by organization and sector.

Make each message worth opening.

6. Are You Treating Donors Like An ATM Machines?

Imagine receiving an email from a nonprofit only when it wants money.

No updates. No stories. No thanks. Just another request.

That gets old.

Donors want to know that their gifts matter. They want to see progress, understand challenges, and feel connected to the people their support helps.

Review your donor communications.

How often do you thank people without asking for another gift? Do you share stories about the difference donations make? Do you recognize long-term supporters?

What to do: Plan at least one meaningful donor update between fundraising appeals. Show what happened because people gave.

7. Is Your Social Media … Social?

Your social media page should not look like a never-ending collection of donation requests and event announcements.

People want useful, interesting and human content.

Review your posts.

How many:

  • Show the people behind your mission?
  • Share a real story?
  • Teach people something useful?
  • Highlight volunteers or supporters?
  • Explain a problem your organization is working to solve?
  • Give people a clear reason to take action?

If every post sounds like an advertisement, people have little reason to follow along.

What to do: Create a balanced content plan. Mix educational posts, stories, impact updates, event promotions, and fundraising requests.

8. Are You Making the Most of Your Videos?

Here’s a question that could save your organization money.

How many videos have you paid to produce over the past three years?

And how many are still being used?

Many nonprofits create videos for galas, annual campaigns, donor appeals, and special events. Then those videos disappear into a folder somewhere.

You could do better.

A strong donor story could become:

  • A short social media video.
  • An email featuring a beneficiary’s story.
  • A section of your fundraising page.
  • A presentation for potential sponsors.
  • A clip for your next event.
  • A donor appreciation message.

You don’t always need another expensive production.

What to do: Make a list of your existing videos. Review their quality, message and relevance. Identify five that could be edited or reused.

9. Does Your Organization Have a Clear Story?

Your mission statement might explain what you do.

Does it make people care?

People need to understand why your work matters. They need to see the problem, the people affected, and the difference your organization makes.

Avoid language that sounds like it came from a grant application.

Instead of saying:

“We provide comprehensive support services to underserved populations.”

Explain what that means.

“We help families find safe housing, put food on the table, and build a better future.”

10. Are You Promoting Events Enough?

A common mistake is treating event marketing as a last-minute activity.

You announce a gala, send a few emails, post some graphics, and hope for the best.

A successful event needs more than a save-the-date graphic.

Review your marketing timeline.

Are you promoting the event months ahead? Are you sharing stories about the cause? Are sponsors receiving materials they can share? Are you giving past attendees to return?

Your event content can help attract next year’s attendees, engage donors, and show sponsors what their support made possible.

What to do: Build a promotion plan for each major 2027 event. Include pre-event, event-day, and post-event marketing.

11. Are You Giving Sponsors a Reason to Work With You Again?

Sponsors want more than their logo on a banner.

They want to know their investment matters.

Review what your organization provides to sponsors before, during, and after events.

Do they receive professional photos? Can they share event videos? Do they get meaningful recognition? Can you show them who attended and what their support helped accomplish?

What to do: Create a sponsor follow-up package. Include photos, short videos, audience information, event highlights and a clear explanation of the impact their support made.

Better sponsor communication helps build stronger relationships before your next sponsorship conversation.

12. Is Your Content Accessible?

Your marketing should reach as many people as possible.

That means considering people with disabilities when creating websites, graphics, emails, and videos.

Check whether:

  • Videos have accurate captions.
  • Images include alternative text.
  • Text has enough contrast.
  • Website forms work with a keyboard.
  • Important information isn’t communicated through color alone.
  • Your website works with common assistive technologies.

Grab our Free Disability Marketing Guide if you want to fast track your accessibility initiatives.

Accessibility should not be an afterthought. It should be part of how you communicate.

13. Are You Giving Your Best Stories Enough Attention?

Your nonprofit has dozens of stories worth sharing.

A volunteer who has dedicated 20 years to your mission. A family whose life changed because of your programs. A donor who started giving because of a personal experience.

Are those stories being told?

Stories help people understand your work in a way that lists of services and statistics often cannot.

What to do: Identify five people whose stories could help explain your impact. With their permission, create a plan to share those stories through your website, email, social media, and fundraising campaigns.

14. Are You Working With the Right Marketing Partners?

This one deserves an honest conversation.

Not every marketing agency understands nonprofits.

Some specialize in pretty graphics. Others focus on website traffic. Some produce beautiful videos and then disappear.

Your organization needs more than someone who can deliver a finished project.

You need partners who understand your goals, audience, challenges and fundraising needs.

Ask your current partners:

  • Do they understand our mission?
  • Can they explain how their work supports our goals?
  • Do they help us find opportunities, or just complete assignments?
  • Do they communicate clearly?
  • Are they helping us make better use of our budget?

What to do: Review every outside marketing relationship. Keep the partners who bring real value. Challenge the ones who cannot explain what their work is accomplishing.

15. Do You Have a Marketing Plan for 2027?

Finally, bring everything together.

You have identified problems, opportunities and areas that need improvement.

Turn those findings into a plan.

You don’t need a 75-page document.

Start with:

  • Three main goals.
  • Five marketing priorities.
  • Your most important campaigns and events
  • A monthly content plan
  • A realistic marketing budget
  • The numbers you’ll use to measure progress
  • The people responsible for each activity

Most importantly, decide what you will stop doing.

Before spending more money in 2027, make sure you’re getting everything you can from the money you’ve already spent.

Want to Get More From Your Nonprofit’s Existing Videos?

At Team Trust Productions, we’re a disability-led video production and marketing company that works with nonprofits.

We believe your marketing should help you reach the right people, build trust, engage supporters, and support your fundraising goals.

We offer a free 15-minute video marketing review.

We’ll look at your existing video content and identify three ways you could get more marketing and fundraising value from it.

Request Your Free 15-Minute Video Marketing Review

Published by Ryan Wilson

CEO of Team Trust

Leave a Reply