Your nonprofit has a social media calendar.
Someone is posting three, four, maybe five times a week. You’ve got pictures from events, program updates, inspirational quotes, awareness days and the fundraising appeals.
The accounts look active.
But …
What is all that activity doing for your organization?
Social media helps nonprofits build trust, reach new supporters, and raise more money. Posting regularly, though, doesn’t guarantee any of those things.
Your nonprofit could spend hundreds of hours creating content that looks great, gets a few likes, and does very little to move your mission forward.
Let’s fix that.
The Problem With Measuring Social Media by Activity
Many organizations measure how much they post.
Those numbers don’t tell the whole story.
Imagine two nonprofits.
Nonprofit A publishes five posts every week. Most feature event announcements, holiday greetings, staff photos, and quotes about making a difference.
Nonprofit B publishes three posts a week. Each has a clear purpose. One introduces a person whose life changed because of the organization’s work. Another explains a problem the organization is solving. The third invites people to take a specific action.
Which organization is doing better?
You cannot know just by looking at how often they post.
Nonprofit B has a better starting point. Its content has a job to do, which is a good start.
Your Social Media Needs More Than One Job
Asking for donations all the time can make your audience tune out. It gets old.
People need reasons to care about your organization before they become ready to support it.
Your social media should serve several purposes.
1. Help new people discover your organization.
Someone who has never heard of your nonprofit should be able to find your content and quickly understand what you do.
Share useful information, surprising facts, short videos and stories that people want to pass along.
2. Help people understand why your work matters.
Don’t just tell people that your programs make a difference. Show them.
Introduce the people behind your mission. Explain the challenges they face. Show what changes when your organization gets involved.
3. Build trust with potential supporters.
People want to know their money and time will make a difference.
Show your team at work. Share program updates. Explain how donations support your mission. Celebrate real progress.
4. Give supporters something to do.
A post without a next step isn’t always a bad post. But if none of your content gives people a reason to act, you’re missing opportunities.
Think of your social media as a path. You want people to move from discovering your organization to eventually supporting it.
If your content only helps people recognize your logo, that path is going nowhere.
The Numbers Your Nonprofit Should Actually Watch
Here are five numbers worth tracking.
1. Reach: Are new people seeing your content?
Reach tells you how many unique people saw a post.
If your nonprofit has 10,000 followers but most of your posts reach only a small portion of them, you have a distribution problem.
Look at which posts reach people beyond your existing audience. Are short videos doing better? Are personal stories getting shared? Are certain topics attracting new people?
Use those findings to guide your next round of content.
2. Engagement: Are people paying attention?
Look at comments, shares, saves, and meaningful conversations.
A post that gets 15 shares may be more valuable than one that gets 100 likes. Why? Shares put your message in front of other people’s networks.
Pay attention to the quality of engagement, too. A comment from someone asking how to volunteer may be more valuable than 20 generic compliments.
3. Website traffic: Are people taking the next step?
Your social media should help people discover more about your organization.
Are visitors clicking through to your website? Which pages are they visiting? Are they exploring your programs, reading your stories, or checking out your upcoming events?
Google Analytics can help you track website traffic and important actions. You can also use tracking links to identify which social platforms and campaigns bring visitors to your site.
4. Are people doing what you want them to do?
This is where things get interesting.
A conversion is an action that matters to your organization.
It could be:
- A completed donation
- A volunteer application
- An event registration
- A newsletter subscription
- A request for more information
- A program inquiry
Track these whenever possible.
You may discover that one platform brings thousands of visitors but very few donations, while another brings fewer visitors who are much more likely to support your organization.
That should guide your decision making.
5. Is social media helping financially?
Ultimately, your nonprofit needs resources to carry out its mission.
Track donations that come directly from social media links, fundraising campaigns and other measurable sources.
Don’t stop there.
Social media can influence a donation that happens later through email, a direct conversation, or an event. Someone might discover your organization on Instagram, visit your website a week later, and donate after receiving an email.
That doesn’t mean Instagram gets full credit for the donation. It does mean social media may have played a role.
The Content Mistake That Makes Many Nonprofits Forgettable
You’re competing with everything — everyone on social media; the Iran war; NFL games on Sunday; NBA games; etc. There are so many distractions.
Your nonprofit may have an incredibly important mission. That doesn’t automatically make every post interesting.
A picture of your organization’s building may mean something to your staff. It may mean very little to someone who has never visited.
A generic quote about kindness may look nice. However … thousands of other organizations can post the same thing.
Your audience needs something more meaningful. Give it a little juice!
Give people a reason to stop scrolling.
Share a short interview with a volunteer explaining why they care. Show what happens behind the scenes at an event. Explain a problem your organization is working to solve.
A well-made 30-second video can communicate emotion, personality and impact in ways that a graphic often cannot.
More importantly, it gives people an opportunity to connect with the humans behind your organization.
Four Changes That Can Make Your Social Media More Effective
You need to make your existing strategy more purposeful.
Here are five changes you can implement today.
1. Give every post a purpose.
Before publishing anything, answer one question:
What should someone think, feel or do after seeing this?
If you cannot answer that question, reconsider the post.
Every post should serve a reason for being there.
2. Create content around your audience, not your calendar.
Awareness days and holidays can be useful; they shouldn’t control your entire content strategy.
Think about what your donors, volunteers and potential supporters actually want to know.
What questions do they ask? What concerns do they have? What would help them understand your work?
Build content around those answers.
3. Make your calls to action specific.
Tell people exactly what to do.
Examples:
- “Register for our upcoming fundraising dinner.”
- “Give $25 to help provide essential supplies.”
- “Share this story with someone who should know about our work.”
- “Sign up for our monthly newsletter.”
- “Volunteer at our next community event.”
Make the next step easy to understand.
5. Review your results
Set aside 30 minutes to review your social media performance.
Ask:
- Which posts reached the most new people?
- Which stories generated the most meaningful engagement?
- Which posts brought visitors to our website?
- Which campaigns generated donations or registrations?
- What should we create more of next month?
- What should we stop doing?
Your Competitors Are Fighting for Attention. Your Nonprofit Should Be Building Relationships, Too.
Social media is much more valuable when you use it to build relationships.
These relationships don’t always produce immediate results.
That’s why your nonprofit needs a consistent message, compelling stories and a clear way for people to take the next step.
This is where your content needs to work together.
Your social media should connect with your website, events, email newsletters and fundraising campaigns. Each channel should help move people closer to your organization.
That’s a much stronger approach than treating every social media post as an isolated activity.
The Bottom Line
Your nonprofit needs to reach the right people, earn their trust, and give them reasons to support your mission.
More posts won’t automatically accomplish that. More followers won’t guarantee it. And a pile of likes won’t pay your organization’s bills.
A thoughtful strategy, meaningful content and regular measurement can make a much bigger difference.
If your social media feels busy but isn’t producing the results you want, it’s time to look beyond the posting schedule.
At Team Trust Productions, we help nonprofits turn their stories into stronger relationships, bigger audiences and measurable growth.
We’re a disability led video production and marketing company. We help nonprofits create compelling fundraising stories, short-form social videos, event content, and marketing campaigns that give their missions more opportunities to be seen and supported.
We offer a free 15-minute video marketing review to help your organization identify three ways to get more marketing and fundraising value from the video content you already have.