Let’s play a little game.
Imagine your nonprofit’s marketing director walks into your office and says:
“Great news! Our latest campaign reached 50,000 people. We gained 800 new followers, and one of our videos received 12,000 views!”
That’s great. Really.
However …
Did any of those people become donors?
Did more people sign up for your programs?
Did you attract new sponsors?
Did existing supporters become more involved?
Did anyone take a meaningful step toward supporting your mission?
Uhhhh. 🙂
If the answer is “I’m not sure,” we have a problem.
And it’s a problem that costs nonprofits time, money, and opportunities.
Nonprofit marketing should accomplish much more than getting attention. It should help people discover your organization, understand why your work matters, trust your team, and take action.
Likes, views, followers, and website visits are all be useful. They’re just not the finish line.
They’re supposed to help you get somewhere.
Let’s talk about where your marketing should actually take you.
1. Marketing should attract more of the right people
Your nonprofit doesn’t need everyone in America to know its name.
It needs the right people to know its name.
Think about the different groups that can help your organization grow:
- People who may become donors
- Companies that could become sponsors
- Foundations and major funders
- Volunteers who can support your programs
- Families who need your services
- Community leaders who can introduce you to new opportunities
- People who can spread the word about your mission
These people have different needs.
One generic marketing message won’t speak to everyone.
Your marketing should help each important audience understand why your organization matters to them.
Look at your last five social media posts, emails or website articles.
Ask yourself:
- Who was each message intended to reach?
- What did we want that person to understand?
- What did we want them to dot?
If you struggle to answer those questions, your content may be creating activity without creating much progress.
2. Marketing should build trust
People don’t always give the first time they hear about a nonprofit.
They may need to see your organization several times before they’re comfortable making a contribution.
They want to know:
- Who are you?
- What do you actually do?
- Who benefits from your work?
- Can I trust you?
- Does my support make a difference?
- Will you still be there tomorrow?
Your marketing should answer these questions.
And it should do so before you ask someone to pull out their credit card.
One of the biggest mistakes nonprofits make is treating marketing like a collection of fundraising announcements.
If every interaction is an ask, supporters can start to feel like walking wallets.
Give people reasons to care before asking them to give.
For example:
- Share a story about someone your organization helped.
- Show what happens behind the scenes.
- Explain a problem your programs are working to solve.
- Introduce the people who make your organization work.
- Share updates that show what previous donations helped accomplish.
Video can be especially useful here.
A well-produced interview with someone who benefited from your programs can help people understand your work in a way that text cannot.
Don’t make the mistake of thinking that one video automatically builds trust.
Trust is built through repeated actions, not just attractive marketing.
3. Marketing should raise money
Let’s get to the subject that matters to almost every nonprofit leader.
Money!
Your marketing should create opportunities to raise money.
So your marketing should support the entire fundraising process.
For example:
Before a fundraising campaign: Introduce the problem, explain why it matters, and help people understand the opportunity to make a difference.
During the campaign: Share stories, answer questions, provide updates, and make it easy for people to contribute.
After the campaign: Thank supporters, show what happened, and explain what comes next.
The last step is super important.
The Association of Fundraising Professionals’ found that charitable dollars raised increased by an estimated 5 percent in 2025. However, the number of donors fell by 3.6 percent.
If your organization celebrates higher fundraising totals without looking at the number of people supporting you, you may miss a growing problem.
What happens if a handful of major donors stop giving?
Your revenue could take a serious hit.
Marketing can help you build a broader base of support by attracting new donors and keeping existing supporters connected to your mission.
Here are three ways to connect marketing to fundraising:
- Tell better donor stories: Show people what their support makes possible. Don’t just describe your programs. Show them.
- Promote your fundraising events: Start building interest before the event. Use email, social media, short videos and personal invitations to encourage attendance.
- Keep donors involved after giving: Share updates, milestones and stories that remind supporters why they chose your organization.
Marketing and fundraising should work together toward shared goals.
4. Marketing should keep supporters involved
What happens between your annual gala, holiday appeal, and major fundraising campaign?
If the answer is mostly silence, you’re missing an opportunity.
Donor relationships need attention throughout the year.
Think about a person who gives $100 to your organization.
They receive a thank-you email.
Then nothing.
Three months pass.
Six months.
Eventually, another fundraising appeal arrives.
Why should that person feel connected to your organization?
They may have forgotten about you.
They may not know what happened with their contribution.
They may still care about your mission, but you’ve given them very little reason to stay involved.
Your marketing should help prevent that.
Here are a few simple ideas:
- Send a short monthly impact update.
- Share a new beneficiary or volunteer story.
- Show progress toward an important goal.
- Introduce a new program or team member.
- Invite donors to an upcoming event.
- Share a short video showing what their support makes possible.
The 2025 CCS Philanthropy Pulse found that 48 percent of organizations reported retaining more than half of their new donors over the previous 12 months.
That means acquiring a new donor is only part of the job. Keeping that donor involved matters, too.
5. Marketing should make your impact easier to understand
Would someone who knows nothing about your organization understand that after spending 60 seconds on your website?
Can they quickly understand:
- What problem you solve?
- Who you help?
- How you help them?
- Why your approach matters?
- What has changed because of your work?
If not, you have a communication problem.
That can affect fundraising, partnerships, program enrollment, and public trust.
Imagine two organizations asking a local company for a $25,000 sponsorship.
Organization A sends a brochure filled with general statements about its mission.
Organization B shares a clear story about its work, introduces the people involved, and provides evidence of the difference its programs make.
Which organization makes it easier for the company to understand the opportunity?
You don’t need to guess.
The second organization has made its case easier to understand.
This is where storytelling becomes powerful.
A short beneficiary interview, a program overview, an event recap, or a documentary style video can help bring your work to life.
Combine human stories with real information.
Your stories help people care. Your evidence helps them believe.
Together, they make a strong case for support.
6. Marketing should give you results you can measure
If you can’t tell whether your marketing is working, how do you know where to spend your money?
You shouldn’t have to guess.
You also shouldn’t judge your marketing team by how many posts they publish or how many followers they gain.
Those numbers tell you what happened. They don’t always tell you whether it mattered.
For example:
| Marketing activity | What you should measure |
|---|---|
| Social media posts | Qualified inquiries, website visits and actions taken |
| Fundraising emails | Donations, revenue and repeat gifts |
| Event promotion | Registrations, attendance and sponsors |
| Donor stories | Donations, donor interest and engagement |
| Website content | Relevant traffic, inquiries and conversions |
| Video campaigns | Views, watch time, clicks and resulting actions |
We’re not throwing away views, likes or clicks.
We’re putting them in the right place.
Every marketing activity should have a clear purpose and a way to measure progress.
You should understand that marketing rarely controls the entire result.
A marketing campaign might attract 100 potential donors, but your fundraising team, donation process, follow-up and donor experience all affect how many actually give.
Measure the full journey. Don’t blame one department for a result that depends on several.
7. Give every marketing campaign a job
Before you publish your next post, send your next email, or produce your next video, answer five questions:
- Who are we trying to reach? Be specific.
- What do we want them to understand?
- What do we want them to feel?
- What do we want them to do?
- How will we measure success?
Let’s say you’re producing a video to promote your annual fundraising gala.
A weak goal would be:
“Create an exciting video that gets lots of views.”
A stronger goal would be:
“Use a 60-second video to encourage previous attendees, local business leaders, and prospective sponsors to visit our event page and register or request sponsorship information.”
The second goal gives your team direction.
It also makes it easier to decide what the video should include, where to publish it, who should see it, and what action to request.
One more tip: Don’t stop measuring when a campaign ends.
Look at what happened 30, 60 and 90 days later when possible.
Some of the most valuable results of marketing happen long after the original post or campaign disappears from your social media feed.
Your marketing should be an investment, not a collection of expenses
Your nonprofit probably spends money on advertising, photography, video, design, marketing software, email platforms, website support and staff time.
Those expenses serve a purpose.
If you’re spending thousands of dollars producing content that nobody sees, nobody remembers, and nobody acts on, something needs to change.
And if an agency or production company delivers a folder full of beautiful videos but has no interest in how those videos will help your organization, ask some harder questions.
You deserve a partner who understands your goals, helps you reach the right people, and thinks about what happens after the content is delivered.
That’s an important difference between simply producing marketing materials and helping a nonprofit move forward.
Team Trust is a disability led video production and marketing company built around helping nonprofits communicate their stories, reach supporters and create more opportunities for growth.
We believe your should help people understand your mission, believe in your work, and take action.
We offer a free 15-minute video marketing review.
We’ll look at your existing video content and identify three ways you could get more marketing and fundraising value from it.
You might already have some of the tools you need. You just need a better plan for putting them to work.